What Is The Next Step If A Child Custody Appeal Is Reversed In Arizona

If your child custody appeal is reversed in Arizona, it means the Arizona Court of Appeals found that the trial court made a legal error that affected the outcome.
The “next step” depends on exactly what the appellate court’s order says — because a reversal can play out in different ways.

1. Read the Mandate Carefully

• The appellate court will issue an opinion explaining the reasons for reversal, followed by a mandate that tells the trial court what to do next.

• A reversal usually does not create a brand-new custody order by itself — it sends the case back to the trial court for more work.

2. Common Outcomes After Reversal

1. Reverse and Remand for a New Hearing

   • Most common in custody cases.

   • The trial court must hold a new evidentiary hearing or redo part of the case, this time following the legal rules the appellate court clarified.

   • You and the other parent can present evidence and testimony again.

2. Reverse and Direct Entry of a New Order

   • Less common, but sometimes the appellate court will tell the trial court to enter a specific order without further hearing — for example, awarding joint custody or changing decision-making authority.

3. Reverse for Clarification / Additional Findings

   • The trial judge keeps the original record but must make new written findings (best interests factors, specific statutory considerations) before issuing a revised order.

3. What Happens in the Trial Court After a Reversal

• The appellate court’s decision is sent back (“remanded”) to the Superior Court.

• The trial court will schedule status conferences or hearings to carry out the appellate court’s instructions.

• The judge is bound by the appellate court’s ruling — they cannot just re-enter the same order without fixing the identified problems.

4. Your Role After Reversal

• Prepare for a New Hearing (if ordered)

  • Update your evidence — especially anything that has changed since the original trial.

  • Be ready to address the specific legal or factual issues flagged by the appellate court.

• Follow Temporary Orders

  • Until the trial court issues a new custody order, the original one often stays in effect (unless the appellate court or trial court changes it temporarily).

5. Possible Further Appeals

• After the trial court enters its new order, either side can appeal again if they believe the new ruling still has legal errors.

• In rare cases, the other parent might petition the Arizona Supreme Court to review the reversal itself.

6. Key Deadlines

• The trial court will act only after the appellate mandate is issued (usually ~15 days after the appellate decision, unless someone seeks reconsideration or Supreme Court review).

• Once remanded, hearing dates can range from a few weeks to several months depending on court scheduling.

Do Child Custody Cases Ever Get Supreme Court Review?

in Arizona, it’s very rare for the state Supreme Court to review a child custody case.

Here’s why and how it happens:

1. How Supreme Court Review Works in Arizona

• After the Arizona Court of Appeals issues its decision, a party can file a Petition for Review with the Arizona Supreme Court.

• The Supreme Court does not have to take the case — review is discretionary (unlike the Court of Appeals, which must hear most family law appeals).

• The justices typically agree to review a case only if it:

  • Raises a new or unsettled question of Arizona law.

  • Resolves a conflict between different appellate decisions.

  • Involves important public policy issues.

  • Addresses constitutional rights with broad impact.

2. Why Custody Cases Rarely Qualify

• Most custody appeals involve fact-specific disputes (e.g., which parent gets primary residence, how parenting time is split).

• The Supreme Court focuses on legal principles that can guide lower courts statewide, not on re-deciding individual family situations.

• Unless your case presents a novel legal question — for example:

  • How Arizona applies custody law to a unique family arrangement.

  • Whether a statute is constitutional.

  • How state law interacts with federal child welfare law.
    — it’s unlikely to be accepted.

3. Examples of Custody-Related Issues That Might Get Review

• Disputes over how Arizona interprets the best interests factors in unusual situations.

• Whether Arizona courts can exercise jurisdiction under the UCCJEA (Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act) in a multi-state custody fight.

• Questions about the limits of parental rights versus third-party rights (e.g., grandparents, step-parents).

• Interpretation of new or amended custody statutes.

4. What Happens If the Supreme Court Takes the Case

• The process is more formal and can take 6–12 months.

• Both sides file supplemental briefs focusing on the legal questions the Court agreed to review.

• There’s usually an oral argument before all seven justices.

• The Supreme Court issues a written opinion that becomes binding precedent for all Arizona courts.

5. If Review Is Denied

• The Court of Appeals decision becomes the final word in your case.

• At that point, your only legal option in the U.S. system would be to petition the U.S. Supreme Court — but they only hear custody cases involving significant federal constitutional questions, which is even rarer.

Child Custody Lawyers In Scottsdale, AZ

[/vc_column_text]

[/vc_column][/vc_row]