What Happens at a Final Custody Hearing?

At a final custody hearing, also known as a trial on custody or final parenting time hearing, a family court judge will hear both sides of a custody dispute and issue a legally binding decision that determines the legal and physical custody of the child or children. Here’s what to expect:

🔷 Overview of a Final Custody Hearing

1. Preparation Before the Hearing

• Pretrial Statements: Each party may submit a pretrial statement summarizing their case, evidence, and requested custody arrangement.

• Discovery Completed: All relevant documents, witness lists, and expert reports (e.g., psychological evaluations) should be exchanged prior to trial.

• Attempts at Settlement: Courts typically require mediation or settlement conferences before a final trial.

2. The Hearing Process

✅ Opening Statements (optional)

• Each parent (or their attorney) may briefly state what they intend to prove.

✅ Presentation of Evidence

• Testimony from Both Parents: Each parent testifies about their relationship with the child, parenting history, and proposed custody plan.

• Cross-Examination: Each side has the chance to question the other’s witnesses.

• Witnesses: This may include:

  • Teachers

  • Doctors

  • Child psychologists

  • Family members

  • Court-appointed experts (e.g., GAL – Guardian ad Litem)

• Documents & Records: School records, communication logs, medical records, etc.

✅ Expert Evaluations (if applicable)

• Reports or testimony from custody evaluators or mental health professionals.

✅ Child Interview (sometimes)

• In some cases, especially when children are older (e.g., 12+), a judge may interview the child privately in chambers.

✅ Closing Arguments

• Each party summarizes their case and urges the court to adopt their proposed plan.

🔷 What the Judge Considers

Judges always prioritize the best interests of the child, based on factors like:

• Each parent’s ability to provide stability, love, and care

• Past involvement in the child’s life

• Child’s physical and emotional needs

• Willingness to co-parent

• Any history of abuse, neglect, or substance use

• The child’s wishes (if appropriate)

🔷 Final Custody Decision

• Legal Custody: Who makes major decisions (school, healthcare, religion)

• Physical Custody: Where the child lives

• Parenting Time Schedule: Specific days/times, holidays, vacations

• Support Orders: Often child support is addressed if not already settled

• Modification Rules: How and when changes can be requested

🔷 After the Hearing

• A court order is issued—this becomes enforceable law.

• Parties must comply or risk contempt of court.

• Appeals may be possible but are limited to legal errors, not dissatisfaction with the outcome.

Preparing For A Child Custody Appeal

Preparing for a child custody appeal is a serious and highly technical process. Appeals are not a “retrial”—they are legal challenges to errors made in the original hearing. To be successful, you must prove that the trial court made a legal or procedural mistake that affected the outcome.

Here’s a detailed guide to help you prepare:

✅ Checklist for Preparing a Child Custody Appeal

🔹 1. Understand What an Appeal Is (and Is Not)

• Not a new trial – You can’t introduce new evidence or re-argue facts.

• Focus is on legal errors – You must identify how the judge made a mistake in applying the law or abused their discretion.

• Timelines are strict – You must act quickly, often within 30 days of the final custody order (check your state’s deadline—in Arizona, it’s typically 30 days).

🔹 2. Consult an Appellate Attorney

• Appeals require specialized legal knowledge. Look for a family law appellate attorney.

• They can assess whether you have a viable legal basis for appeal.

• They’ll also handle procedural steps like filing the Notice of Appeal, preparing the Record on Appeal, and drafting the Opening Brief.

🔹 3. Request and Review the Trial Record

• The record includes:

  • Court transcripts

  • All filed motions, evidence, and orders

  • Audio/video of proceedings (if available)

• This is your evidence on appeal—you cannot add new items.

🔹 4. Identify Appealable Issues

Common appealable errors include:

• Judge ignored or misapplied state custody laws

• Denial of your right to call witnesses or present evidence

• Ruling was not supported by the evidence presented

• Improper bias or misconduct by the judge

• Incorrectly admitted or excluded evidence

• Denied due process

🔹 5. Draft and File the Opening Brief

• This is your primary document—it outlines:

  • The facts of the case

  • Legal standards

  • Errors made by the trial court

  • How those errors affected the outcome

• Must follow strict formatting, citation, and word count rules.

🔹 6. Expect a Response and Possibly Oral Argument

• The opposing party can file a response brief defending the original ruling.

• Some appeals courts allow oral arguments before a panel of judges, but not all.

🔹 7. Know the Possible Outcomes

• Affirmed: The custody ruling stands.

• Reversed: The ruling is overturned.

• Remanded: Sent back to the lower court for a new hearing or further proceedings.

• Modified: The appellate court makes specific changes to the order.

📌 Arizona-Specific Notes (if you’re appealing in AZ):

• File a Notice of Appeal with the Superior Court that issued the order.

• Arizona Court of Appeals handles family law appeals unless the Supreme Court intervenes.

• You may need to request transcripts from court reporters within 10 days of filing.

🛠️ Tips for Success

• Keep a paper trail of everything from the original trial.

• Stay focused on legal errors, not emotions or dissatisfaction with the outcome.

• Be prepared for a long process (often 6–12 months or more).

• Avoid violating the custody order during the appeal—it can hurt your case.

Child Custody Lawyers In Scottsdale, AZ

[/vc_column_text]

[/vc_column][/vc_row]