Family courts make decisions with the child’s best interest as the primary focus. This means the courts will consider several factors based on the child’s safety and well-being. The court ultimately uses this standard when choosing between guardianship and adoption. Let’s look at the pros and cons associated with these options.
What Is A Guardianship?
If you are the legal guardian of a child, you have the rights and legal responsibilities to care for that child until they reach majority age. A guardian is the child’s primary caregiver. You or a judge may also revoke this legal relationship, if necessary.
Parents can also be guardians, but guardianship is often implemented when a minor child needs someone else to make legal decisions. Parents will keep their parental rights and responsibilities in a guardianship.
Pros Of Guardianship
There are many benefits associated with guardianship, including the following points made below.
- Authority To Make Decisions: You will be able to make decisions on the child’s behalf until they typically turn 18 years old.
- Financial Support: If you become a guardian, you may be eligible for payments like foster parents. Guardians of the estate are responsible for managing its financial assets.
- Legal Protection: Formal guardianship gives you the legal authority to act on behalf of another person.
What Is Adoption?
Unlike guardianship, adoption will terminate the biological parents’ rights. Guardianship is typically used when someone other than a biological parent is taking care of the child. This can be a close family friend or even a family member who adopts the child.
Pros Of Adoption
It’s essential for anyone considering adoption to carefully weigh these pros and cons, conduct thorough research, and seek guidance from adoption professionals, counselors, and support groups. The decision to adopt should be made with a full understanding of the challenges and rewards involved, as well as a commitment to providing a loving and stable home for the adopted child.
- Providing A Loving Home: Adoption allows individuals or couples to provide a loving and stable home for a child who may not have had such an opportunity otherwise. It gives children a chance to grow up in a caring family environment.
- Fulfilling Parenthood Dreams: For individuals or couples facing fertility challenges or those who are unable to have biological children, adoption offers the chance to fulfill their dreams of parenthood.
- Expanding Family: Adoption allows families to grow through a new addition, fostering sibling relationships and enriching the family dynamic.
- Giving A Child Opportunities: Adopted children have the opportunity to access education, healthcare, and opportunities that they might not have had in their birth families.
- Helping Birth Parents: Birth parents who choose adoption may feel relieved knowing their child will be raised in a stable and loving environment. They also have the opportunity to pursue their own goals and well-being.
- Legal Rights And Responsibilities: Adoptive parents typically gain legal rights and responsibilities for the child, including decision-making authority, inheritance rights, and the ability to provide healthcare and education.
- Variety Of Adoption Types: There are different types of adoption, including open, semi-open, and closed adoptions, which offer varying degrees of contact and information-sharing with birth parents. This allows adoptive families to choose the level of openness that suits their preferences and the child’s needs.
Differences Between Guardianship And Adoption
As a parent and/or caregiver, you will ultimately decide whether guardianship or adoption is best for your child’s needs. Use the following bullet points to help you choose between adoption and guardianship.
| Guardianship | Adoption |
| Parents’ legal rights remain intact. | Severs legal rights of the biological parents. |
| Guardianship is temporary. | Adoption is permanent. |
| Parents may be required to provide child support. | Parents have no obligation to provide child support. |
| Guardians must stipulate a provision in their will. | Child can inherit from their adoptive parents. |
Need Family Law Attorneys In Scottsdale?
The High Desert Family Law Group should be your first choice when you need the best divorce lawyer in Scottsdale or Phoenix, Arizona. Our experienced family law attorneys will work with you to obtain the best possible outcome in your situation. Proven trial lawyers in family court, you can trust the firm to represent you fully so you can get on with your life. Call today for your initial consultation.
